|
PHYSICIAN ANTITRUST EXEMPTION LEGISLATION RECENTLY PROPOSED AT BOTH STATE & FEDERAL LEVELS COULD IMPACT HEALTH CARE COSTS
02 July 2001 - Boston University
| Physician antitrust exemption legislation recently proposed at both the state and federal levels could impact health care costs and considerably alter the relationship between physicians and managed health care plans. Researchers from Boston University School of Public Health and the Agency for Health Care Research and Quality recently published their analysis of this significant legislative development in the July 3rd issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association. |
Physician antitrust exemption legislation recently proposed at both the state and federal levels could impact health care costs and considerably alter the relationship between physicians and managed health care plans. Researchers from Boston University School of Public Health and the Agency for Health Care Research and Quality recently published their analysis of this significant legislative development in the July 3rd issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association. Under current antitrust law, physicians are largely prohibited from joining together and negotiating fees with managed care plans. Antitrust policy supports the principle that competition within the marketplace promotes consumer welfare. When competing entities join together and agree on fees or prices, it can be viewed as price fixing by antitrust officials. Fee negotiations by groups of physicians from different practices with managed care plans, therefore, are often in violation of antitrust policy. Physicians claim that current antitrust policy places them at a competitive disadvantage in their negotiations with managed care plans. They contend that while most physicians belong to practices that treat a small proportion of the population in their market, the consolidation among health plans has given the managed care plans substantial market power. Critics of the legislation claim that the law would enhance the economic power of physicians and increase health care costs, making health care less affordable for consumers. In the District of Columbia, where physician antitrust exemption legislation passed, the financial control board blocked implementation of the law due to concerns about its impact on cost of care. In many of the states where this legislation has been proposed, the new law if passed, would likely impose significant limits on physicians' ability to collectively negotiate fees. However, a federal bill proposed last year would have provided almost all physicians the opportunity to join together to negotiate fees. The federal bill was intended to give physicians union-like status for purposes of negotiating with managed care plans. "While it is unlikely legislation at the state level would noticeably alter the balance of power between physicians and managed care plans, federal legislation would considerably change the physician/managed care plan relationship, shifting the power towards the physician," said Gary Young, PhD, JD, associate professor of health services at BUSPH, and co-author of the JAMA article. "Unfortunately, there is little research about the potential impact of such legislation on health care costs to guide policy makers."
http://www.bu.edu/
About: Boston University
Boston University has a well-deserved reputation for excellence in research in a wide range of disciplines and a demonstrated commitment to fostering innovative interdisciplinary research. The Office of the Associate Provost for Research and Graduate Education supports the University in facilitating research at the both the student and faculty levels.Our mission is to enhance and encourage research at Boston University and to provide a climate conducive to maintaining the University at the cutting edge of research and scholarly activities. We work with the Boston University community to plan and coordinate interdisciplinary research and represent the University in research matters related to Inter-University consortia. To encourage new, innovative, and cross-disciplinary efforts, this office administers the Special Program for Research Initiation Grants (SPRInG). We showcase graduate research at Science & Technology Day. This annual event features nearly 200 research posters by graduate students from both the Medical and Charles River Campuses working in a wide range of disciplines. Our annual research magazine, Research at Boston University, informs a wide audience about a selection of our significant research findings and ongoing studies at Boston University. We also maintain a strong presence on the web through this site and through the Science Coalition’s website, which brings our research successes to the attention of Congress and other policy makers in the federal government. To assist Boston University researchers, this office oversees the Undergraduate Research Opportunities Program and coordinates with the Office of Sponsored Programs on the Charles River Campus , the research administration on the Medical Campus, the Office of Research Compliance, and the various graduate programs. For the development of commercially viable ideas, we administer the Provost's Innovation Fund and work closely with the Office of Technology Transfer. We also coordinate proposals where there are institutional limits to the number of proposals that may be submitted, cost sharing requirements, significant laboratory renovations, or other special circumstances. This office assists departments and centers to achieve a diverse faculty and graduate student body through our membership and activities with the Northeast Alliance for Graduate Education and the Professoriate and through our affiliation with the Clare Boothe Luce program of the Henry Luce Foundation. |
More News:
• For July 2001
• From Boston University
• For University
|
